Writer Sanctum

Writer's Haven => Marketing Loft [Public] => Topic started by: Marti Talbott on July 12, 2019, 04:54:31 AM

Title: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Marti Talbott on July 12, 2019, 04:54:31 AM
I asked Written Word Media if they promoted to Kindle Unlimited readers. They sent me this link. https://readingstacks.com/for-authors

If we don't have to drop the regular price to zero, it makes promoting KU books a lot easier. I'm just now checking it out.
Title: Re: New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: OfficialEthanJ on July 12, 2019, 05:24:23 AM
Not easier for me. None of my titles have 20+ reviews, despite my efforts.
Title: Re: New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Marti Talbott on July 12, 2019, 05:29:24 AM
Not easier for me. None of my titles have 20+ reviews, despite my efforts.

Understood, some of mine don't have 20 reviews yet. It takes time to build that up.
Title: Re: New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: 123mlh on July 12, 2019, 06:36:01 AM
Nice. They have better categories for romance than Freebooksy did last time I checked.
Title: Re: New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Anarchist on July 12, 2019, 08:08:48 AM
Not easier for me. None of my titles have 20+ reviews, despite my efforts.

Another argument for building and maintaining an ARC list.

It's the difference between waiting a year (or longer) to accrue 20+ reviews and having them posted at launch (technically, pre-launch).

Title: Re: New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Maggie Ann on July 12, 2019, 08:44:26 AM
The price is right and the book that I'll be putting back in KU in September has 60+ reviews and an audiobook. I'll keep this in mind. Thanks, Marti.

Title: Re: New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: TimothyEllis on July 12, 2019, 11:39:51 AM
Doesn't anyone else find their list size of exactly 10,000 suspicious?

Make me thing they email spam.
Title: Re: New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Marti Talbott on July 12, 2019, 11:55:56 AM
Well, I'm on their list for the 25th, so I'll let you know.
Title: Re: New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Marti Talbott on July 12, 2019, 11:58:14 AM
It's the same company as Freebooksy, and I've never had a problem. I think 10,000 is an estimate because it's new? For only $25.00 it's worth taking a chance for me.
Title: Re: New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Maggie Ann on July 12, 2019, 12:56:57 PM
It's the same company as Freebooksy, and I've never had a problem. I think 10,000 is an estimate because it's new? For only $25.00 it's worth taking a chance for me.

Me, too.

I think they just rounded their subscriber figures, probably up but that's okay.

Freebooksy is way too expensive for me with little results. I've tried Bargainbooksy for 99c books and the results were absolutely dismal.

Let us know how it goes.
Title: Re: New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: OfficialEthanJ on July 12, 2019, 01:05:55 PM
Not easier for me. None of my titles have 20+ reviews, despite my efforts.

Another argument for building and maintaining an ARC list.

It's the difference between waiting a year (or longer) to accrue 20+ reviews and having them posted at launch (technically, pre-launch).

Maybe in my next life, I guess. Since I don't promote titles beyond the first in the series, and being that I'm in KU, the A in ARC would mean "After the Fact". I'm not super worried about it re: my existing slate of offerings. If people have something to say about it, they will, but overall they seem to read my stuff into the ground and I get paid. Maybe my next series I'll do the ARC thing before I gum it up with KU.
Title: Re: New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Simon Haynes on July 12, 2019, 01:44:47 PM
I booked an audiobook promo for one of mine - I probably only need to sell 2 copies to cover the cost, although since they have such a small mailing list I doubt I'll even do that. I just never find time to promote my audio, so this is like chucking a bone in the general direction ;-)
Title: Re: New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: KevinH on July 17, 2019, 01:21:25 PM
The repetitive 10,000 did seem odd, but there are so few viable platforms for promoting audio that I gave them a whirl.  (Plus, they're in the same family as Freebooksy/Bargain Booksy, so they were worth a roll of the dice.) On the day my promo was supposed to run, I got an email in the early afternoon saying my book would start hitting the inboxes of readers between 8pm and 11pm.  Seriously.  That means my promo "day" might be as little as one hour (not to mention possibly arriving late at night).

Needless to say, the promo was an epic fail.  I'm assuming they're still working the bugs out, but hopefully others will have better luck than I did.
Title: Re: New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: notthatamanda on July 17, 2019, 08:49:20 PM
Written word media usually sends out a survey asking for feedback for FreeBooksie and Red Feather so you can let them know if you get that.  Sorry you had such bad results, I know how disheartening a busted promo is.
Title: Re: New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: KevinH on July 18, 2019, 12:51:03 AM
Yes, I completed the survey and told them of the results, and also - among other things - how I viewed the timing of the email as a strategic/marketing failure.
Title: Re: New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: TimothyEllis on July 18, 2019, 12:56:18 AM
my book would start hitting the inboxes of readers between 8pm and 11pm.  Seriously.  That means my promo "day" might be as little as one hour (not to mention possibly arriving late at night).

This sort of thing is why a 1 day promo needs the book on special for 3 days.

If the email comes early, the book is already on special. If the email is late, there is still more than 24 hours for people to act on it.

Its safe to assume that a lot of people wont have a chance to act on a promo email for up to a day after getting it. As such, you need to leave the book on special for at least a day after.
Title: Re: New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: KevinH on July 18, 2019, 02:47:54 AM
This is for books in KU and audiobooks, so there's really no "special" from the standpoint of discounting. However, any rank/visibility/momentum you might get from sales or borrows is going to be of little benefit if it's kicking in when most people are snoozing.  There are other factors as well, but I think they need to beta test this a little more before they start offering it as a viable option.
Title: Re: New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Ghost5 on July 18, 2019, 05:09:31 AM
Well, this is depressing to read. I booked a slot with them tomorrow. My book is first in series and priced at $2.99. I'm hoping for a KU boost.

I'll check back in with results.
 :catrun
Title: Re: New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Marti Talbott on July 18, 2019, 05:13:42 AM
I have one for the 25th. Hope this gets straightened out by then!
Title: Re: New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: KevinH on July 18, 2019, 06:13:31 AM
Well, mine may not be the typical experience, so I'll definitely be interested in how others fare. 
Title: Re: New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: LilyBLily on July 18, 2019, 09:18:53 AM
I'm not sure an 8 PM target time is so bad. That's about when most adults with jobs or lives are looking for some entertainment and may not be too picky about what it is.
Title: Re: New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Marti Talbott on July 18, 2019, 09:27:43 AM
 Another problem may have been that it was prime days. My sales were dismal, and it's normal for the dashboard to be behind. At least it used to be. I remember when Gaga (whoever that is) did a free song giveaway and it took three days for book sales to catch up.

Anyway, Kevin, did you ask them directly if it was an error or their standard method?
Title: Re: New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Anarchist on July 18, 2019, 10:15:37 AM
8:00 to 11:00 p.m. is a terrible time to email.


(https://cdn2.hubspot.net/hubfs/53/HubSpot_Sales_Images/site_page_images/best-time-to-email.png)

Source: https://blog.hubspot.com/sales/best-time-send-email-report-2015


Written Word should know better.
Title: Re: New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: KevinH on July 18, 2019, 10:50:09 AM
I'm not sure an 8 PM target time is so bad. That's about when most adults with jobs or lives are looking for some entertainment and may not be too picky about what it is.

To be clear, it was between 8pm and 11pm.  So it might have gotten there at 8pm, might have gotten there an hour before midnight.  Personally, if I weren't an author, 8pm would be well past the time I would be checking email. I'd be kicking back with a book, watching some tube, or something along those lines.

I didn't ask if the timing was standard, but the email pretty much looked like a form letter so I assumed that to be the case.  That said, I just looked at it again and it does say that I shouldn't expect a one-day sales spike like there would be with a price promotion; instead, I should anticipate a bump in page reads and audiobook downloads in the weeks following the promotion. 

I agree with the statement about the sales spike, and I wasn't really anticipating any.  However - as stated - I was looking for page reads and audio sales.  Long story short, there really haven't been any - at least none that I'd attribute to the promo.  More to the point, they seem to be indicating that the results may not become evident until several weeks down the road. If you've engaged other promotions since then, how do you know what to attribute to Reading Stacks vs your other efforts (e.g., a newsletter swap, a KU promo with another platform, etc.)?

In essence, the way it's currently structured, I think it's going to be very difficult to assign to value to this particular offering.  They need to revamp it in a way that offers a somewhat measurable benefit.



Title: Re: New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: notthatamanda on July 18, 2019, 10:54:49 AM
8:00 to 11:00 p.m. is a terrible time to email.


(https://cdn2.hubspot.net/hubfs/53/HubSpot_Sales_Images/site_page_images/best-time-to-email.png)

Source: https://blog.hubspot.com/sales/best-time-send-email-report-2015


Written Word should know better.


They do for Freebooksy.  From my feature in June:

Your book will start hitting the inboxes of our readers between 11am and 2pm EST today.
Thanks for your business and good luck with your promotion!
The Written Word Media Team
Title: Re: New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Anarchist on July 18, 2019, 11:11:36 AM
8:00 to 11:00 p.m. is a terrible time to email.


(https://cdn2.hubspot.net/hubfs/53/HubSpot_Sales_Images/site_page_images/best-time-to-email.png)

Source: https://blog.hubspot.com/sales/best-time-send-email-report-2015


Written Word should know better.


They do for Freebooksy.  From my feature in June:

Your book will start hitting the inboxes of our readers between 11am and 2pm EST today.
Thanks for your business and good luck with your promotion!
The Written Word Media Team


Before you said that, I was thinking, "8:00 to 11:00 p.m.?! That's ridiculous."

Now I'm thinking, "That's ridonkulous."

It's so bizarre, it's almost funny.

Almost.


Title: Re: New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Marti Talbott on July 19, 2019, 11:46:21 PM
I got an email from this company last night. Yep, last night. It showed up at 8 pm central time promoting four books.

Maybe they do have a problem. Maybe someone is confused between a.m. and p.m.?
Title: Re: New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: notthatamanda on July 20, 2019, 12:06:06 AM
I got an email from this company last night. Yep, last night. It showed up at 8 pm central time promoting four books.

Maybe they do have a problem. Maybe someone is confused between a.m. and p.m.?
Which promo site?  Freebooksy, etc?
Title: Re: New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Marti Talbott on July 20, 2019, 12:31:40 AM
I got an email from this company last night. Yep, last night. It showed up at 8 pm central time promoting four books.

Maybe they do have a problem. Maybe someone is confused between a.m. and p.m.?
Which promo site?  Freebooksy, etc?

Reading Stacks - the one that promotes books in KU and audio. It is part of the Written Word Media, and I think it's new. The email I got only had 4 books, 3 Mystery and one Science Fiction. By the way, they rejected my earthquake book. I understand. It is hard to put in a genre. They did accept a mystery, "Missing Heiress."

https://readingstacks.com/for-authors
Title: Re: New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Ghost5 on July 20, 2019, 03:34:09 AM
Hey, y'all--

I listed with them yesterday (the 18th) for a first book in series to try to boost KU. First off, I'd say they're still new enough that they only send a newsletter once per week--certainly not every day. Someone correct me if it's more frequent than once every week.

Yes, they sent me a confirmation email that their NL would go out between 8 - 11 pm.

Yes, I received my newsletter at 7 pm, straight on the dot (I'm central time, US).

No, I didn't see a significant drop in my ranking for that book to indicate any significant downloads. I'll amend this post if today perks up, but at this point, my opinion is that it's too early in this promotion site's existence to throw money at it. Maybe it'll get better with more subscribers and time, but for now, it's disappointing.

Save your money. At least for now.
 :catrun

p.s. Marti--you can edit your subscriber details on the NL list so you get the categories of books you prefer. I checked their website and they featured 16 books in total. I'd say you only got four due to your preferred genres. I also subscribed but didn't get quite what I'd asked for and had to edit (so I could see my own book!).
Title: Re: New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Marti Talbott on July 20, 2019, 03:40:43 AM
Good way to test the once a week email. Mine is set up for 7/25 which is next Thursday. I'm so new to KU, I didn't actually know you can tell when the rank changed. Good to know.
Title: Re: New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: notthatamanda on July 23, 2019, 03:32:50 AM
I had to contact Written Word Media about something else so I mentioned that people were concerned about the timing of the emails for Reading Stacks.  Incidentally, they are using that same timing for New to Read (I think that is what it is called).  Anyway, they'd like to hear from you guys directly, if you are so inclined.

I hope everyone's okay with that, I didn't give them any names or even tell them what forum it was, though they asked.

Here's the email they sent me:

Hi Amanda,

Thanks again for letting us know about this! We would greatly appreciate it if you would direct the authors in the forum to our customer service team. They can email us at hello@writtenwordmedia.com to share their feedback with us.

All the best,


Teisha M
The Written Word Media Team
Title: Re: New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Marti Talbott on July 23, 2019, 03:40:16 AM
I let them know I was concerned because my promotion is coming out on the 25Th. This is the response I got. (By the way, I see no harm in telling them about this forum.)

Hi Marti,

Thanks for reaching out to us! Yes, our Reading Stacks emails are scheduled for Thursday nights at 8pm EST. Thank you for sharing your feedback with us. I'll be sure to pass your concerns along to our leadership team.

All the best,


Teisha M
The Written Word Media Team
Title: Re: New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Marti Talbott on July 25, 2019, 11:18:28 PM
 My promotion is today. Apparently, they listened to us about the time of day their emails go out.

"This is to confirm your feature of Missing Heiress: A Jackie Harlan Mystery by Marti Talbott is now live on Reading Stacks.

Your book will start hitting the inboxes of our readers between 10am and 12pm EST today. Please keep in mind that Reading Stacks readers generally download books and audiobooks via their subscription services. As such, you will not see a one-day sales spike in your retail dashboards as you do when running a price promotion. Instead, you can anticipate a bump in KENP reads and/or audiobook downloads in the weeks following your promotion."

I'll keep everyone posted. Mine is just for page reads, not audio.

By the way, it hit my mailbox at 7:20 a.m. central time.
Title: Re: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: notthatamanda on July 26, 2019, 12:01:03 AM
Good luck with your promo.
Title: Re: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Marti Talbott on July 26, 2019, 12:14:00 AM
The promotion email with my book in it came out just now 8:10 am.

Can someone explain how to tell if someone downloaded a book, but has not started reading it yet? Are those the ones that just have a 1 page read, or is there another way to tell?
Title: Re: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: TimothyEllis on July 26, 2019, 12:17:22 AM
Can someone explain how to tell if someone downloaded a book, but has not started reading it yet? Are those the ones that just have a 1 page read, or is there another way to tell?

1 page is a good indication of a download. But if you get 6, you cant tell if that was 6 downloads or 6 pages read after 1 download.

Amazon don't tell us how many downloads we got. You can try to reverse guestimate it from rank changes, but its not very reliable.
Title: Re: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: notthatamanda on July 26, 2019, 12:51:25 AM
I've found rank changes to be really slow these days which wouldn't help the guestimating.
Title: Re: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Lu Kudzoza on July 26, 2019, 02:54:44 AM
The promotion email with my book in it came out just now 8:10 am.

Can someone explain how to tell if someone downloaded a book, but has not started reading it yet? Are those the ones that just have a 1 page read, or is there another way to tell?

Compare yesterday's page rank (if you know it) to today's and tomorrow's. Then you can estimate the number of downloads. However, what really matters is how many page reads you get over the next several weeks compared to the last few weeks.
Title: Re: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Marti Talbott on July 26, 2019, 03:07:19 AM
The promotion email with my book in it came out just now 8:10 am.

Can someone explain how to tell if someone downloaded a book, but has not started reading it yet? Are those the ones that just have a 1 page read, or is there another way to tell?

Compare yesterday's page rank (if you know it) to today's and tomorrow's. Then you can estimate the number of downloads. However, what really matters is how many page reads you get over the next several weeks compared to the last few weeks.

I messed up, sort of, and scheduled a free promotion on Amazon select for today and tomorrow, so the rank looks pretty good, (5,713) but I doubt I can contribute that to the paid ad. I'll get this figured out, really I will.

On another note, I only have two books in KU that meet their requirements. Missing Heiress is one with 55 reviews, and the other one, Seattle Quake, has many, but it got rejected because they don't have a category it fits into. So this will be my only true test.

Missing Heiress
Page reads today so far - 272
Title: Re: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: KevinH on July 26, 2019, 10:51:21 AM
I actually purchased 3 promos when I discovered the service (but before the issues with it came to light), so I have one running today as well.  Likewise, I also received the message stating that the email would go out between 10am and noon.  Thus, they get points for being responsive, if nothing else.

As to the effectiveness of the promo, I'm not convinced it did anything.  I ran it on the first book in my Warden series, but that book is part of a Kindle Countdown this week (99 cents), so it was already in the public eye, so to speak.  That said, it did get some page reads, but I'm attributing that to the fact that I plugged it in my newsletter yesterday, and it's probably picking up some love from the release of the audiobook for Book 3, which happened a few days ago.  (As evidence of this, Book 3 is currently ranked about 3700 on Audible, while Book 1 and Book 2 enjoyed a nice rank improvement to about 17,000 and 13,000, respectively.)

My third promo runs next week, but it's on my scifi novel Terminus that was just part of a 99-cent BookBub deal this past Sunday, so - assuming there's a tail - I think it will be difficult to measure the promo's effectiveness.

Title: Re: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Marti Talbott on July 27, 2019, 12:11:45 AM
The day after - looks like two people read my book yesterday, but can't tell how many downloaded it. I think this is a great idea basically, it will just take time for them to gather enough readers to make it worth the money..
Title: Re: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Maggie Ann on September 17, 2019, 11:47:52 PM
I scheduled with them for 9/26 and I have no other promos running for this book any time around there. I'm hoping for whispersync sales because that's usually what puts me over the top with my other books that have audio.

I'll report back when I have some figures.

Title: Re: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: notthatamanda on September 18, 2019, 12:14:04 AM
Good luck!
Title: Re: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Maggie Ann on October 03, 2019, 11:48:31 PM
My promo ran on Thursday, 9/26, so I thought it was time to report results. The book I promoted is the first in series consisting of two novellas and a related cookbook. All three are priced at 99c. This used to be my most popular book and I chose to promote this one because I wanted to see if I could revive it. Apparently not. Reading Stacks isn't the first service I tried for it. I also did a promo before I took it off wide and went back into KU. Also dismal results. It does have 69 reviews (4.4 ****) on Amazon and 3.71 on Goodreads.

905 KENP
12 Paid including two each of the 2nd and 3rd books
1 Audio

Cost of the ad was $25 and I made 9.46. That's approximate since I don't know exactly how much the KENP payout is going to be and I'm not completely sure if the audio sale was a whispersync. It most likely was so that's the figure I used. Even if I was slightly off, the final total is not going to change by more than a few cents.

Would I do it again? Yes, but not with this book.

Title: Re: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Marti Talbott on October 04, 2019, 12:43:39 AM
My promo ran on Thursday, 9/26, so I thought it was time to report results. The book I promoted is the first in series consisting of two novellas and a related cookbook. All three are priced at 99c. This used to be my most popular book and I chose to promote this one because I wanted to see if I could revive it. Apparently not. Reading Stacks isn't the first service I tried for it. I also did a promo before I took it off wide and went back into KU. Also dismal results. It does have 69 reviews (4.4 ****) on Amazon and 3.71 on Goodreads.

905 KENP
12 Paid including two each of the 2nd and 3rd books
1 Audio

Cost of the ad was $25 and I made 9.46. That's approximate since I don't know exactly how much the KENP payout is going to be and I'm not completely sure if the audio sale was a whispersync. It most likely was so that's the figure I used. Even if I was slightly off, the final total is not going to change by more than a few cents.

Would I do it again? Yes, but not with this book.

For KU books, the Amazon free days are working better for me than my attempt at reading stacks. Maybe they just don't have the readership yet. Most of my KU books don't have enough reviews yet, and my one attempt didn't make my money back either. Have to wait for them to grow a little more, I guess.
Title: Re: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Maggie Ann on October 04, 2019, 03:26:10 AM
My promo ran on Thursday, 9/26, so I thought it was time to report results. The book I promoted is the first in series consisting of two novellas and a related cookbook. All three are priced at 99c. This used to be my most popular book and I chose to promote this one because I wanted to see if I could revive it. Apparently not. Reading Stacks isn't the first service I tried for it. I also did a promo before I took it off wide and went back into KU. Also dismal results. It does have 69 reviews (4.4 ****) on Amazon and 3.71 on Goodreads.

905 KENP
12 Paid including two each of the 2nd and 3rd books
1 Audio

Cost of the ad was $25 and I made 9.46. That's approximate since I don't know exactly how much the KENP payout is going to be and I'm not completely sure if the audio sale was a whispersync. It most likely was so that's the figure I used. Even if I was slightly off, the final total is not going to change by more than a few cents.

Would I do it again? Yes, but not with this book.

For KU books, the Amazon free days are working better for me than my attempt at reading stacks. Maybe they just don't have the readership yet. Most of my KU books don't have enough reviews yet, and my one attempt didn't make my money back either. Have to wait for them to grow a little more, I guess.

What promo do you do with the Amazon free days? It's been a long time since I've been in KU.
Title: Re: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Marti Talbott on October 04, 2019, 03:43:23 AM
My promo ran on Thursday, 9/26, so I thought it was time to report results. The book I promoted is the first in series consisting of two novellas and a related cookbook. All three are priced at 99c. This used to be my most popular book and I chose to promote this one because I wanted to see if I could revive it. Apparently not. Reading Stacks isn't the first service I tried for it. I also did a promo before I took it off wide and went back into KU. Also dismal results. It does have 69 reviews (4.4 ****) on Amazon and 3.71 on Goodreads.

905 KENP
12 Paid including two each of the 2nd and 3rd books
1 Audio

Cost of the ad was $25 and I made 9.46. That's approximate since I don't know exactly how much the KENP payout is going to be and I'm not completely sure if the audio sale was a whispersync. It most likely was so that's the figure I used. Even if I was slightly off, the final total is not going to change by more than a few cents.

Would I do it again? Yes, but not with this book.

For KU books, the Amazon free days are working better for me than my attempt at reading stacks. Maybe they just don't have the readership yet. Most of my KU books don't have enough reviews yet, and my one attempt didn't make my money back either. Have to wait for them to grow a little more, I guess.

What promo do you do with the Amazon free days? It's been a long time since I've been in KU.

Go to your dashboard, then bookshelf, and find the book you have in KU. It will say "Promote and advertise" under Kindle Ebook Actions. Scroll down and you'll find a place to set up a giveaway. You only get five free days per three months, so I usually just do one day at a time. Last month I ran one on Seattle Quake 9.2 and got over 800 downloads. It's exposure, and netted over 27,000 page reads. Don't know how many page reads were the result of the downloads. Hope this helps.
Title: Re: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Maggie Ann on October 04, 2019, 04:31:51 AM
My promo ran on Thursday, 9/26, so I thought it was time to report results. The book I promoted is the first in series consisting of two novellas and a related cookbook. All three are priced at 99c. This used to be my most popular book and I chose to promote this one because I wanted to see if I could revive it. Apparently not. Reading Stacks isn't the first service I tried for it. I also did a promo before I took it off wide and went back into KU. Also dismal results. It does have 69 reviews (4.4 ****) on Amazon and 3.71 on Goodreads.

905 KENP
12 Paid including two each of the 2nd and 3rd books
1 Audio

Cost of the ad was $25 and I made 9.46. That's approximate since I don't know exactly how much the KENP payout is going to be and I'm not completely sure if the audio sale was a whispersync. It most likely was so that's the figure I used. Even if I was slightly off, the final total is not going to change by more than a few cents.

Would I do it again? Yes, but not with this book.

For KU books, the Amazon free days are working better for me than my attempt at reading stacks. Maybe they just don't have the readership yet. Most of my KU books don't have enough reviews yet, and my one attempt didn't make my money back either. Have to wait for them to grow a little more, I guess.

What promo do you do with the Amazon free days? It's been a long time since I've been in KU.

Go to your dashboard, then bookshelf, and find the book you have in KU. It will say "Promote and advertise" under Kindle Ebook Actions. Scroll down and you'll find a place to set up a giveaway. You only get five free days per three months, so I usually just do one day at a time. Last month I ran one on Seattle Quake 9.2 and got over 800 downloads. It's exposure, and netted over 27,000 page reads. Don't know how many page reads were the result of the downloads. Hope this helps.

Thanks. I seem to remember I used to do three days and two days, but that's a really good result for only one day at a time.

Title: Re: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: KevinH on January 22, 2020, 08:06:08 AM
Anyone used them lately?  I was contemplating trying them again but wanted to see if anyone was able to comment on recent experiences with them.

Title: Re: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Marti Talbott on January 22, 2020, 09:14:53 AM
The last time I looked, their dates were way out. I guess they're only promoting once a week. It might be worth waiting for, but I would rather put my money on something that happens a little faster. On the other hand, I don't know of any other place that promotes books in KU.
Title: Re: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: notthatamanda on January 22, 2020, 09:29:05 AM
Back when I was in KU I asked Booknights on Fiverr to consider running a KU promotion. Not sure if they ever did anything with that but you can ask them.
Title: Re: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: KevinH on January 22, 2020, 09:32:03 AM
The last time I looked, their dates were way out. I guess they're only promoting once a week. It might be worth waiting for, but I would rather put my money on something that happens a little faster. On the other hand, I don't know of any other place that promotes books in KU.

Yes, some of the dates are out there - no availability until March or after.  On the plus side, there also seems to be more transparency with the numbers (i.e., they no longer have 10K subscribers in every category).  I've asked if they have an average of page reads or audio sales one can expect, but I'm not sure that info will be forthcoming.
Title: Re: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: natasha on January 23, 2020, 05:42:58 AM
Since they don't have average numbers posted for bargain booksy, I doubt they're going to post it for this service either.
Title: Re: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: KevinH on January 23, 2020, 11:28:06 AM
Since they don't have average numbers posted for bargain booksy, I doubt they're going to post it for this service either.

I thought it was worth asking since BookBub and a couple of others put numbers out there. (I was hoping they'd want to be competitive on all fronts.) Anyway, they wrote back and said that they don't have average data per genre.  However, they can provide data on any book you've run, as long as it's within 30 days of the promotion.

Title: Re: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: natasha on January 23, 2020, 12:42:53 PM
I just realized that they wouldn't be able to tell if a someone borrowed a book. But I guess they can provide click counts?
Title: Re: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Marti Talbott on January 23, 2020, 12:44:38 PM
I just realized that they wouldn't be able to tell if a someone borrowed a book. But I guess they can provide click counts?

That's true. Good point.
Title: Re: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: KevinH on January 23, 2020, 03:51:50 PM
I just realized that they wouldn't be able to tell if a someone borrowed a book. But I guess they can provide click counts?

That's true. Good point.

They can also send a survey, like others do.
Title: Re: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Marti Talbott on April 10, 2020, 11:36:59 AM
I finally got a promotion for Kindle Unlimited. Their promotion dates are still way out and I had to wait a month after I paid for it (science fiction). It's running today, and it's annoying because according to KU no one is reading Seattle Quake 9.2 or any of my other books. The rank dropped from 111,258 to 23,401. The beta is showing two actual sales, the reports are not. If only two sales can drop the rank that low, then no one is selling books today.

I'm just sitting here screaming at the reports, "Do something already!"

Title: Re: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: TimothyEllis on April 10, 2020, 01:02:37 PM
The rank dropped from 111,258 to 23,401.

That is KU downloads. The reads will probably turn up tomorrow.
Title: Re: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Marti Talbott on April 10, 2020, 01:15:09 PM
The rank dropped from 111,258 to 23,401.

That is KU downloads. The reads will probably turn up tomorrow.

That's encouraging. Years ago, everything was in real time. Not so anymore and not so for a couple of years.
Title: Re: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: TimothyEllis on April 10, 2020, 01:26:06 PM
The rank dropped from 111,258 to 23,401.

That is KU downloads. The reads will probably turn up tomorrow.

That's encouraging. Years ago, everything was in real time. Not so anymore and not so for a couple of years.

I see this on day releases all the time. You get the rank, but the majority of the reads turn up on day 2. People download, disconnect from the internet, read, then sync up the next day. You get the reads then. The only day 1 reads you get are the fast readers, and those who are always syncing with the net while they read.
Title: Re: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: alhawke on April 11, 2020, 04:21:00 AM
I'm confused here (putting up a book on KU for the first time). How is this promotion site geared more to KU? How does it target reads versus buys?
Title: Re: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Marti Talbott on April 11, 2020, 04:25:21 AM
I'm confused here (putting up a book on KU for the first time). How is this promotion site geared more to KU? How does it target reads versus buys?

It's part of the Written Word Media group (Freebooksy) and it's a new site that only promotes books that are in Kindle Unlimited and audio for that specific market. https://www.readingstacks.com/
Title: Re: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: alhawke on April 11, 2020, 05:06:44 AM
Doh. Stupid me.

Thanks, Marti. I thought there was some special sales method for KU they were using. I understand now that they just gear their promotions to an audience primarily interested in KU.

Anyone know if they let you promote with Bargain Booksy/or Freebooksy at the same time?
Title: Re: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Marti Talbott on April 11, 2020, 05:18:24 AM
Doh. Stupid me.

Thanks, Marti. I thought there was some special sales method for KU they were using. I understand now that they just gear their promotions to an audience primarily interested in KU.

Anyone know if they let you promote with Bargain Booksy/or Freebooksy at the same time?

Anyone know if they let you promote with Bargain Booksy/or Freebooksy at the same time?
They do.  grint
Title: Re: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Marti Talbott on April 15, 2020, 02:24:17 AM
So my first experience with this company promoting Seattle Quake 9.2 went pretty well. Although the promotion was geared toward Kindle Unlimited readers, I sold 4 regular copies with about 4,000 page reads. Follow-up page reads for McShane's Bride (the Dotsero Train Wreck) increased by 2,000. I think that's because I included the first chapter of McShane's Bride at the end of Seattle Quake 9.2, with a direct link, making it easy for the reader to "one click" to immediately download it, plus I ran an AMS ad. Not bad for only $30.

A little over 16k page reads for this month so far. It doesn't seem like a lot to some people, but only about half my catalog is in KU and they are the mystery books that weren't selling very well wide.

Now, If I can just think of a new book to write. After ten years, this is the first time I've run into this problem.

 
Title: Re: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Bill Hiatt on April 16, 2020, 01:11:51 AM
So my first experience with this company promoting Seattle Quake 9.2 went pretty well. Although the promotion was geared toward Kindle Unlimited readers, I sold 4 regular copies with about 4,000 page reads. Follow-up page reads for McShane's Bride (the Dotsero Train Wreck) increased by 2,000. I think that's because I included the first chapter of McShane's Bride at the end of Seattle Quake 9.2, with a direct link, making it easy for the reader to "one click" to immediately download it, plus I ran an AMS ad. Not bad for only $30.

A little over 16k page reads for this month so far. It doesn't seem like a lot to some people, but only about half my catalog is in KU and they are the mystery books that weren't selling very well wide.

Now, If I can just think of a new book to write. After ten years, this is the first time I've run into this problem.
It definitely sounds as if it was a worthwhile investment. (And to me 16K sounds like a fair amount. From what I've seen, as the number of books in KU keeps rising, my numbers continue to go down.)
Title: Re: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Marti Talbott on April 16, 2020, 01:54:50 AM
So my first experience with this company promoting Seattle Quake 9.2 went pretty well. Although the promotion was geared toward Kindle Unlimited readers, I sold 4 regular copies with about 4,000 page reads. Follow-up page reads for McShane's Bride (the Dotsero Train Wreck) increased by 2,000. I think that's because I included the first chapter of McShane's Bride at the end of Seattle Quake 9.2, with a direct link, making it easy for the reader to "one click" to immediately download it, plus I ran an AMS ad. Not bad for only $30.

A little over 16k page reads for this month so far. It doesn't seem like a lot to some people, but only about half my catalog is in KU and they are the mystery books that weren't selling very well wide.

Now, If I can just think of a new book to write. After ten years, this is the first time I've run into this problem.
It definitely sounds as if it was a worthwhile investment. (And to me 16K sounds like a fair amount. From what I've seen, as the number of books in KU keeps rising, my numbers continue to go down.)
Thanks Bill.
Our publishing world seems to be changing a lot and perhaps it is the bandwidth problems after all. If it is, hopefully it will catch us up as some point. We can only hope anyway.
Title: Re: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Marti Talbott on May 17, 2020, 03:22:06 AM
Looks like this site is steadily building readers, so I suggest everyone promote them on Facebook, your site, twitter, etc. The more readers they have the better for us.

https://readingstacks.com/online-reads
Title: Re: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: alhawke on May 17, 2020, 06:36:55 AM
Here's my take. I'm totally new to KU so I don't even know if this KU read stat is good.

I used Reading Stacks on May 7th, but it was part of a very large launch promo with other sites including Bargain Booksy & ENT the days prior. And on my day with Reading Stacks, I was simultaneously running Red Feather Romance & Fussy Librarian. I got just shy of 1k reads at 998 page reads the day of the promo. My record is 1370 three days later. I averaged about 1k throughout the week.

It's so difficult to ascertain where the page reads are from. And, KU readers have never heard of me until 2 weeks ago as my other three books are published wide. That's got to impact it, right? Interestingly, I sold the highest the day of Reading Stacks at 58 sales, but I really think a lot of the sales was due to Red Feather Romance.

The whole page KU thing is an experiment for me and, so far, I'm not all that impressed. I could have landed the same $ in sales wide with my launch but the hope is for a tail, extra exposure, and possibly more reviews. I also understand that KU elevated my rank. I'm keeping an eye on my reads but if it doesn't add up in 3 months, I'm returning my book to wide. Hope my stats give you some idea.
Title: Re: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Bill Hiatt on May 18, 2020, 12:55:23 AM
Here's my take. I'm totally new to KU so I don't even know if this KU read stat is good.

I used Reading Stacks on May 7th, but it was part of a very large launch promo with other sites including Bargain Booksy & ENT the days prior. And on my day with Reading Stacks, I was simultaneously running Red Feather Romance & Fussy Librarian. I got just shy of 1k reads at 998 page reads the day of the promo. My record is 1370 three days later. I averaged about 1k throughout the week.

It's so difficult to ascertain where the page reads are from. And, KU readers have never heard of me until 2 weeks ago as my other three books are published wide. That's got to impact it, right? Interestingly, I sold the highest the day of Reading Stacks at 58 sales, but I really think a lot of the sales was due to Red Feather Romance.

The whole page KU thing is an experiment for me and, so far, I'm not all that impressed. I could have landed the same $ in sales wide with my launch but the hope is for a tail, extra exposure, and possibly more reviews. I also understand that KU elevated my rank. I'm keeping an eye on my reads but if it doesn't add up in 3 months, I'm returning my book to wide. Hope my stats give you some idea.
My experience is that it takes KU readers longer to find things than buying readers. I don't know why, but I see a consistent pattern with new releases: sales first, then reads. Older books fluctuate considerably over time, but they nearly always bring in more pages than new releases until the release is at least two weeks old. What happens after that depends on how much exposure in general the new release has had and how well it's doing. If it's picked up a good number of sales, the number of pages read is far higher than if it hasn't, though there is a definite uptick either way.
Title: Re: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Marti Talbott on May 18, 2020, 01:26:05 AM
Here's my take. I'm totally new to KU so I don't even know if this KU read stat is good.

I used Reading Stacks on May 7th, but it was part of a very large launch promo with other sites including Bargain Booksy & ENT the days prior. And on my day with Reading Stacks, I was simultaneously running Red Feather Romance & Fussy Librarian. I got just shy of 1k reads at 998 page reads the day of the promo. My record is 1370 three days later. I averaged about 1k throughout the week.

It's so difficult to ascertain where the page reads are from. And, KU readers have never heard of me until 2 weeks ago as my other three books are published wide. That's got to impact it, right? Interestingly, I sold the highest the day of Reading Stacks at 58 sales, but I really think a lot of the sales was due to Red Feather Romance.

The whole page KU thing is an experiment for me and, so far, I'm not all that impressed. I could have landed the same $ in sales wide with my launch but the hope is for a tail, extra exposure, and possibly more reviews. I also understand that KU elevated my rank. I'm keeping an eye on my reads but if it doesn't add up in 3 months, I'm returning my book to wide. Hope my stats give you some idea.

I'm so bad at keeping track of everything, I don't believe I've ever tried using more than one promotion at a time. When I do, I usually only keep track for the first three days and then assume the following downloads of a free books are word of mouth, or for some other reason.
Title: Re: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Bill Hiatt on May 18, 2020, 01:43:05 AM
Here's my take. I'm totally new to KU so I don't even know if this KU read stat is good.

I used Reading Stacks on May 7th, but it was part of a very large launch promo with other sites including Bargain Booksy & ENT the days prior. And on my day with Reading Stacks, I was simultaneously running Red Feather Romance & Fussy Librarian. I got just shy of 1k reads at 998 page reads the day of the promo. My record is 1370 three days later. I averaged about 1k throughout the week.

It's so difficult to ascertain where the page reads are from. And, KU readers have never heard of me until 2 weeks ago as my other three books are published wide. That's got to impact it, right? Interestingly, I sold the highest the day of Reading Stacks at 58 sales, but I really think a lot of the sales was due to Red Feather Romance.

The whole page KU thing is an experiment for me and, so far, I'm not all that impressed. I could have landed the same $ in sales wide with my launch but the hope is for a tail, extra exposure, and possibly more reviews. I also understand that KU elevated my rank. I'm keeping an eye on my reads but if it doesn't add up in 3 months, I'm returning my book to wide. Hope my stats give you some idea.

I'm so bad at keeping track of everything, I don't believe I've ever tried using more than one promotion at a time. When I do, I usually only keep track for the first three days and then assume the following downloads of a free books are word of mouth, or for some other reason.
There are good reasons for doing one promotion at a time. It's really the only way to tell how well a promotion is working.

That said, I tend to run mine, not all at once, but spread out over several consecutive days. I can't tell as much about the effectiveness of each individual promo, but the book develops more momentum that way.
Title: Re: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: alhawke on May 18, 2020, 01:48:54 AM
Bill - Thanks. I hope so. It was a good launch as far as sale #s. I'm hoping for a little stickiness.
Marti - I've got a pretty good handle, I think, on what promos do well. Some of them are tried and true, like ENT, but Reading Stacks with KU reads is something else. I have a hunch it helped, but I'm not sure. (BTW, you threw me with your new cover. I didn't know it was you. Looks great!)
Title: Re: Reading Stacks - New place to promote - new to me anyway
Post by: Bill Hiatt on May 18, 2020, 02:36:54 AM
Yes, it is a good cover. I think I've liked all of Marti's covers that I've seen.