One thing the author doesn't mention (and might not know) is that high advances come with their share of risk.
When the publisher gives an author high advances, they expect a large amount of sales. If the sales don't come, they're quick to drop the author. It's super common! No idea how she didn't know it.
But, now I also understand why a lot of medium publishers have been going down the last couple of years, which was highlighted in another thread here. If they are really offering that much in advances, and cant see the books wont earn them back in advance, the publishers are also stupid doing stupid.
But the way trad publishing is that they'll lose on nine authors and earn out on one. It's a terrible system for the midlisters.
Years back I went to a conference for bands and musicians. An experienced producer told me something I'll never forget:
"Record companies aren't interested in selling. They are interested in finding the new hit." He explained that it was the reason why they dropped moderately but steady selling artists, for example.
Well, record companies have gone down the drain, but the logic is the same for big publishers.
It's Las Vegas, baby! They want the new "insert hot name here", and they'll place bets. They'll lose often, but considering how they dominate some markets (bookstores, for example), they are still winning enough to keep playing.
This is big 6 logic, there are exceptions in smaller publishers and imprints. Anyway, if you understand that it's about betting, some bizarre behaviours make more sense.
Why would they
not market a book series for which they paid a quarter million? It could be because circumstances changed and they realized it's not a hot bet, or they have a hotter bet to which they're directing their resources. Maybe they have only so many books in a genre, and they can't market them all equally. They'll focus on the ones that they believe can hit the jackpot.
The company always wins. Out of so many bets, a few are going to make it. There are only a handful of big 6 publishers and the big hits are still coming from them, with few exceptions. The individuals are screwed (including acquisitions editors, agents, not to mention authors, of course).
The growth if indie publishing could eventually change the scene.