Another rec for Elementor.
I got the pro version ($49 pa). No regrets. I was especially excited yesterday when I successfully integrated the forms with MailChimp.
I used it with Generate Press Theme, because it was recommended to me as being light weight and, like you, I had decision fatigue so went with it. It seemed to have all the widgets and whatnot that I could ever possibly need.
The thing about Elementor is that, once you figure it out, you can do heaps with it, and override the theme to make it look how you want.
Not sure of your skill level. For me, I know nothing about coding, except very basic HTML. I had used Wordpress before, but in a job where there was a dedicated web team, so I did a couple of Udemy courses first, because I got them on special -- Wordpress for Beginners by Andrew Williams and an Elementor one. These helped orient me, although I didn't finish the Elementor course. (I mention these because I think Udemy has a sale on now too, so the courses will be about US$10.) Once I started using Elementor, I figured it out. Ok, so there was a bit of swearing, but I ended up with an acceptable site and now the skills to make changes quickly and easily.