I also left Bluehost. I think its hosting has steadily deteriorated over time. I was having weird performance issues (like something as simple as approving comments often caused the site to slow to a crawl).
I use A2 Hosting and couldn't be happier. My experience is with one of the VPS hosting plans, so a cheaper one would probably mean slower performance, but if your needs are simple, it's likely you don't really need that much horsepower.
I have needed tech support a couple of times and found it most helpful and relatively quick. If the on-call chat person can't resolve the issue, support uses a ticket system, and tickets are responded to relatively quickly. (BH only issued a ticket in catastrophic circumstances. Normally, the chat person tried a quick fix, which often didn't work.)
You may not want to do this if your existing site is in a mess, but free migration comes with some A2 plans. That's a real timesaver, but if your site is as badly compromised as it sounds like, you're probably better off starting from scratch.
It doesn't sound like your needs will grow, but if they do, I understand A2 hosting does upgrades very quickly.
Coincidentally, A2 Hosting is currently having a sale.
https://www.a2hosting.com/